Depression Isn’t A Personality Trait

By Alisa BidwellApril 27, 2021

This piece mentions the topic of self-injury. Please use your discretion.

I used to think of my mental illness as a bad personality trait. When I was young, it was chalked up to the natural emotions of growing up. I wasn’t depressed, just hormonal. When I was in high school, it became harder to ignore. I was constantly moving in and out of periods of feeling so low that I couldn’t do anything, to then beating myself up for having been too “weak” to fight it off. I began to self-harm as a way to wake myself up out of these moments when I felt too low to function. The pain reminded me that I needed to be better, stronger. Being able to see the scars made me feel like the hurt wasn’t on the inside anymore and I could move on. Yet, the cycle never ceased.

I was constantly hoping for someone to save me. I wanted someone to tell me that the pain I felt wasn’t normal and that it could be fixed, but instead I was told that I was “overreacting” or “dramatizing.” I came to see my depression as this negative component of myself that I should have been able to control or conquer. I only needed to fight harder. If I could overcome those feelings then I would be able to know how to be happy.

When I went off to college and eventually entered the workforce afterward, I moved away from all my major support systems. I didn’t have friends to validate my feelings or distract me from them, so I began to succumb to it all. I eventually replaced self-harming with an eating disorder.

The “fight” no longer seemed like one I could win, so I used food to numb the pain. It wasn’t until the disorder had completely taken over my life that I resigned myself to seeking some sort of help. Feeling depressed still seemed like a natural part of me, but the eating didn’t and that’s what ultimately got me through the door.

I began seeing a therapist, one that I actually liked for once, and she proceeded to lay down some hard truths about the beliefs that I was holding about my mental illness. The one that ultimately hit the nail on the head came after I’d spent 20 minutes berating myself for not being able to fix what was wrong with me. She put a halt to the monologue, looked straight into my tear-soaked eyes, and said quietly, “Alisa, you’re depressed.”

She explained that what I was feeling wasn’t a test of willpower. If it was, I would have won ages ago. I was doing everything I was supposed to—exercising, going to therapy, using healthy coping methods, but nothing was helping. From there, she encouraged me to ask my doctor about medication.

It took two separate attempts at taking medication before I started to recognize how much it was working. Now, instead of completely overtaking me, I could recognize the “otherness” of my depression. It was a separate thing from the “me” that I liked, and creating that distance between it and myself made it so much easier for my coping methods to start working. When I sensed it trying to drag me down, I could jump into exercise, call a friend, read a book, or go for a drive and it would ebb. I was no longer fighting a battle I couldn’t win.

Depression is not a bad part of my personality or a flaw in my character—it is an illness that I receive treatment for so I can live my life despite its existence. My mental illness does not make me any less valuable. Sure, I have flaws—I’m a bit of a pessimist, struggle speaking to new people, and am a truly terrible singer (though that doesn’t stop me)—but the fact that I deal with a mental illness is not one of them.


Depression has a way of making us feel incredibly isolated. We’re here to remind you of the truth that you are not alone. We encourage you to use TWLOHA’s FIND HELP Tool to locate professional help and to read more stories like this one here. If you reside outside of the US, please browse our growing International Resources database. You can also text TWLOHA to 741741 to be connected for free, 24/7 to a trained Crisis Text Line counselor. If it’s encouragement or a listening ear that you need, email our team at info@twloha.com.

Leave a Reply

Comments (9)

  1. Maja

    Beautifully written! Thanks for sharing, I think it’s really important to speak about this

    Reply  |  
  2. Magda

    A very open and honest converstion about needing to come to terms with mental illness along side with the stigma and unlearning it all. Beautifully written, thank you for your insight!

    Reply  |  
  3. Tammy Copland

    Your story is so similar to mine. I started with self harm at 14 which turned into an eating disorder by 17. I suffer from ptsd and depression which have always felt like a dirty word. Even family would say ‘can’t you just get over it now’. I find myself justifying myself and apologising for my weekness. I have been down these past few weeks believing myself to be a terrible, useless person,
    who shouldn’t be here. Reading your story was the realisation that I needed, and it literally and metaphorically pulled me back up. I thank you. I wish i had the courage to share my story too x

    Reply  |  
    1. TWLOHA

      Tammy,

      You are always welcome to share your story, if and when you are ready, with us. It can be through email (info@twloha.com) or you’re welcome to submit a blog for consideration by sending it to blog@twloha.com. But remember: your story is important, whether you share it or not.

      With Hope,
      TWLOHA

      Reply  |  
  4. John

    Thanks

    Reply  |  
  5. Chelsie

    This post as incredibly helpful for me. Thank you for sharing your story.

    Reply  |  
  6. Susan

    Thank you so much for sharing. Depression doesn’t define who we are. It’s an illness like any other. We are strong people with sensitive hearts.

    Reply  |  
  7. Ashlynn

    I love this. The fact that I/m not the only one that sees that it’s not a personality trait makes me happy. When people see me at school all they see is “depression” or that’s what they call it, but I don’t see how you can see depression just by looking at someone and not knowing them personally. Yes, I wear dark clothes but that doesn’t mean I wear them because I’m depressed, maybe I just like them. I’m tired of people just looking at me and thinking that I’m depressed without even knowing me. I’m a person and I should be viewed as one. I get compared to people because I don’t look or act like them but it shouldn’t matter because I’m myself and not them. They see me and they see depression but also they make fun of me and tear me apart and then wonder what they’re going to see back. But what I’m trying to say is you shouldn’t be judged for something you can’t control. Then getting told to get over it is like telling someone to get over a disease.

    Reply  |  
    1. TWLOHA

      We agree, Ashlynn. Depression is a mental health challenge and it looks different for everyone. Judgment and misconceptions only encourage stigma to thrive and people to keep their situations a secret. Thank you for doing what you can to combat this.

      With Hope,
      TWLOHA

      Reply  |  
Get Email Updates

Sign up for our newsletter to hear updates from our team and how you can help share the message of hope and help.

Join our list